Andrew, now at the University of North Texas, penned these reviews back in late 2006. His wit and erudition in reviewing early music are much missed…
Geminiani: Concerti Grossi (CD 15076). Francesco Geminiani’s British contemporaries deemed him the equal of Handel and Corelli, but little of his musical or theoretical output is extant outside the concerti grossi, a few sonatas, and the violin treatise The Art of Playing on the Violin (MT262.G32 1751). The concerti grossi, arrangements of Corelli’s Opus 5 sonatas, have become a staple of the baroque orchestra repertoire. Here, Chiara Banchini and Ensemble 415 apply their native sensibilities to the works, emphasizing the energetic and virtuosic tendencies of Geminiani and his generation; for contrasting interpretations, see CD 3588 (I Musici), CD 7991 (Tafelmusik), and (my favorite) The Academy of Ancient Music with Andrew Manze.
Beethoven: Mödlinger Tänze (CD 15077). Beethoven left Bonn in 1792 to study with Haydn in Vienna, who in November had his Katharinentänze performed at the annual Retirement Society of Visual Artists ball. As Haydn made trips to London over the next few years, apparent tension began to form between the two; however, Haydn probably had a hand in obtaining an invitation for Beethoven to write dances for that same function in 1795. These dances, as well as some ascribed to Beethoven and two by his brother Kaspar Karl appear on this collection, performed by Michi Gaigg and the L’Orfeo Barockorchester. The interpretation is solid and without frills, a fitting testament to Beethoven’s developing compositional method within stylistic constraints.
Vivaldi: Concerti a liuto solo (CD 15078); Sanz: La Preciosa (CD 15079). Like the sands of the hourglass, so are albums of Vivaldi concerti. Fortunately, Paolo Cherici has taken a fresh approach and arranged several for solo lute, to magnificent effect; his strength is in the economy of the arrangements, using no more material than is absolutely necessary, and creating a derivative Affekt that feels very much authentic. Gordon Ferries’ recording of Gaspar Sanz, on the other hand, features selections from the Instrucción de música sobre la guitarra española and revels in its idiosyncratic style. Being the most complete guitar treatise of its time, the Instrucción contains 90 pieces, mostly based on dance forms such as the folía, canario and españoleta. Ferries allows the writing to speak for itself naturally through his instrument, and it serves as a nice counterpoint to Cherici’s effort.
Boccherini: Fandango, Sinfonie & La Musica Notturna di Madrid (CD 15080). All notions of native performance practice aside (see Early Music 20:4, page 649), it was only a matter of time before Jordi Savall got around to recording some Boccherini. Luckily, he chose the right repertoire: the “Fandango” quintet and La Musica Notturna delle Strade di Madrid are about as stereotypically Spanish as Boccherini got, and Savall’s blessed heritage comes in handy for their interpretation. Rolf Lislevand and Manfredo Kraemer are at their usual energetic best, but it is the presence of José de Udaeta on castanets that brings the listener to the busy streets of Madrid, making palpable the tension between Boccherini’s quest for solitude and the necessity of pleasing new patrons.
Muzyka w dawnym Wrocławiu (CD 15081). Under Habsburg rule from 1526-1742, the Polish city of Wrocław (Breslau in German) had a vibrant musical life that fostered Protestant church music while incorporating elements of Venetian polychoral style, enjoying a ‘golden age’ of organ building, and producing the acclaimed lutenist Silvius Leopold Weiss (see CD 13060). Jan Tomasz Adamus and Harmonologia display this richness as they present sacred works for voice and instrumental ensemble by Wolf-Ernst Rothe, Christoph Bernhard, and Johann Hermann Schein. Bringing it all together is the precision and amazing balance of Concerto Palatino and Bruce Dickey, one of the world’s foremost cornetto players (see CDs 6077, 10754, and 14151).
Boismortier: La Veloutée (CD 15082); Hotteterre: La Nopce Champêtre (CD 15083). Joseph Bodin de Boismortier was a prolific composer of music mostly intended for amateurs in various combinations of instruments, including such fashionable choices as the musette (a small bagpipe), hurdy-gurdy, and transverse flute, whose repertoire he extended significantly. This recording features his earliest sonatas for keyboard and flute (Op. 91, c1741–2), which give the two complementary roles (common practice was harpsichord-dominant). Les Buffardins, no strangers to this repertoire (see CD 14150), lilt their way through Boismortier’s refined phrases and personify the elegant simplicity of amateur chamber music of the time.
On the other side of the spectrum are the works of Jean and Jacques-Martin (“Le Romain”) Hotteterre, which embody the earthier side of French flute-centered chamber music. The Hotteterres are credited with developing the first prototypes of the Baroque oboe, bassoon, and flute; their talent for instrument making, performance, composition, and pedagogy formed the foundation of the French woodwind school. Here the Ensemble Le Berger Fortuné lively interprets some highly pictorial works, such as the programmatic genre painting-evoking La Nopce Champêtre ou L’Himen Pastoral, using the musette and hurdy-gurdy to great sonic effect.
Jordi Savall: Mozart Serenate Notturne (CD 15102), Orient-Occident (CD 15103); Concerto Köln: The Mozart Album (CD 15104), Mozart (CD 15105), Dream of the Orient (CD 15106). Mozart’s 250 th birthday inspired a slew of recordings, and apparently Savall couldn’t resist. It doesn’t really bring anything new to the table as far as repertoire or interpretation, just another solid Mozart period performance (although it is nice to hear Manfredo Kraemer stretch out on some classical repertoire). Concerto Köln is at least creative with their programming, including the overtures to Betulia liberate (K. 118), Der Schauspieldirektor (K. 486), and music from the ballet Les Petits Riens (1778). Their more standard selections, Symphonies 29, 35 (“Haffner”), and the D major Divertimento (K. 136/125a) benefit from energetic tempi and clearly vigorous enjoyment of performing unquestionably great music.
The coincidental (?) focus by both groups on music of the Orient (paging Edward Said) provides a contrasting view of two very different approaches to this concept. Savall’s is more successful, achieving a quieter chamber texture that allows the native performers and instrumental timbres to dialogue with each other readily. His repertoire choice also favors the Eastern sources, in keeping with the explanation that the project was the “unconscious search for a spiritual antidote to [… the] war in Afghanistan.” Concerto Köln, on the other hand, prefers to remain firmly rooted in the Western impressions of The Orient and sprinkles in authentic music for an exotic effect. Unfortunately, over-reliance on Gluck’s and Kraus’s ideas makes the album fall flat, which is a shame, because it opens with a strong sequence of Turkish-inspired improvisation leading directly into the Overture to Die Entführung aus dem Serail, and it ends with Franz Xaver Süssmayr’s “Sinfonia turchesca.”
Mozart: Clarinet quintet, “Kegelstatt” trio (CD 15154). Quatuor Mosaïques’ recordings of Mozart, Haydn, and Beethoven on period instruments are clear and expressive, and this effort is no exception. Basset clarinetist Wolfgang Meyer joins the group for a joyful romp through the Clarinet Quintet, perhaps one of the most sublime pieces of large-ensemble chamber music in Mozart’s catalog. Patrick Cohen steps in on Hammerflügel (also known as Grand pianoforte) for the “Kegelstatt,” playing nicely off of the basset and the viola’s lines and evoking a texture very different from that of the quintet. A pleasure for both Kenner und Liebhaber.
Homilius: Musik an der Dresdner Frauenkirche / Kantaten I (CD 15158). After taking composition and keyboard lessons from Bach while studying law in Leipzig, Gottfried August Homilius became organist at Frauenkirche, Kantor at the Kreuzkirche, teacher of the Kreuzschule, and music director of the three main churches in Dresden. This recording features cantatas written (and performed) by the Kreuzchor, and makes for a very engaging listen. About his style Hans John has written: “He gave new life to the church cantata after J.S. Bach. […] In his vocal works Homilius followed the example of C.H. Graun in emphasizing melody, naturalness and folklike simplicity. The works are rooted in the era of Bach and Handel, but at the same time increasingly show pre-Classical traits as Homilius’s style matured. Along with Doles, Homilius is the main representative in church music of the transitional empfindsamer Stil, in which heterogeneous elements are fused into an artistic whole.” Indeed, these traits are well represented in the performance of the Dresdner Kreuzchor and Barockorchester, which clearly take delight in performing music written specifically for their musical ancestors and presenting a refreshingly different perspective of late-Baroque German cantatas.